Reykjavik Edition: Twenty bucks a course

Even with the Icelandic krona trading for about 10% less against the dollar than it did a month ago, Reykjavik has to be the most expensive city I've ever visited. Think about how much more expensive things in Hawaii are compared to California. Now think of Iceland as the Hawaii of Scandinavia. The prices would make even a Tokyo native blush.
As a rule of thumb, food in Reykjavik cost about twice what it would cost in Manhattan--Midtown Manhattan, that is. But even in Reykjavik, where a half-hour cab ride to the airport costs about $140, I managed to find a few standout courses that, if not entirely affordable, at least kept me from having to go to the local (surprisingly popular) Subway branch.
My favorite spot was Sægreifinn, a shanty on the water in the city center. Here, you'll find three long tables arranged cafeteria-style, with a counter where you can order lobster soup (about $10), or kebabs made with scallops (about $20), whale ($14), or potato ($2--whew!). The minke whale, cooked medium rare, had the taste and texture of about two parts steak and one part liver (unlike the puffin I had the night before, which was more like half steak, half liver); the scallops were freakishly large, and not worth it when considering the fact that you could get an equal portion of lobster for the same price. The lobster, mind you, was some of the best I've ever had. It was nicely grilled, with plenty of garlic sprinkled for good measure, but pleasantly rare in the center--making it just sweet and melty, like the flavor of a good raw shrimp or squid. But the lobster soup is what stole the show. Creamy, salty, and fishy at the same time, the whole thing reminded me of a lighter version of bisque, but with plenty of nice lobster chunks inside. It's easy to imagine a grizzled Icelandic sailor stepping in from the bitter cold for a hot bowl of this soup.
Lobster soup and minke whale at SægreifinnLater at night, I hit up Nonnabiti for a Lambabátur (lamb sandwich, about $15) that was nearly magical. Served with a creamy "special sauce" (who knows?), lettuce, dried onions (maybe) and pickles, the lamb is sliced paper-thin, and cooked to crisp up around its edges. The crisping is critical, as it gives the lamb meat a bacon-y texture that ... well, is bacon-y. And who can argue with that?
Apparently, there is a Nonnabiti vs. Hlölla-Bátar rivalry in Reykjavik that is not unlike the Pat's vs. Geno's controversy in Philadelphia. I'm sorry to say that I can't report on the difference, as the choice was made easy for me: you have to order your Hlölla-Bátar sandwiches outdoors. At least that gives me an excuse to return to Reykjavik in the summer.
Sægreifinn
Geirsgata 8, 101 Reykjavík
Tel. +354 553 1500
Nonnabiti
Hafnarstræti 11, 101 Reykjavík
Tel. +354 551 2312




